The DMs did pretty well this session; things were a bit late to start, due to some issues with scripts, but the NPCs were believable and the interactions were pleasant.
The session ended up as all RP, due to our collective inquisitive nature, so I can't much give a score on rewards or challenge; those scores are my trying to remember what I gave for the last sessions, so that I don't influence the numbers.
03/23/10
7
8
10
8
8
6
9
10
7
7
03/23/10
6
9
8
7
9
7
5
10
7
8
Caanbow and Raganui were new to DMing at this adventure, and I think they handled it remarkably well. The adventure was obviously a starting adventure (though it might've been less obvious if we players didn't sit about staring at the plot hook for so long). All in all, a fun game.
[Caanbow's reply to comment: Admittedly, I got a kick out of how it seemed that the players tried to skirt around it. So I kept hitting them with it over and over. I felt like I was giving you people a concussion :(]