 |
|
| 03/23/05 |
Comments in reference to the character Joe Malsmith a Human: I liked the stow-away idea, it made everything come together.
|
|
|
|
| 03/23/05 |
Comments in reference to the character Joe Malsmith a Human: Nice roleplayed. Good headstart with being a stowaway! It was really good roleplaying.
|
|
|
|
| 03/23/05 |
Comments in reference to the character Joe Malsmith a Human: (Add Comments Here)
Mr. Joe was a great, if not slightly nutty, addition to the party. His roleplaying was a breath of fresh air and slightly apart from the norm, which was a pleasant surprise.
Sure. I‘d love to work with him again.
|
|
|
|
| 03/23/05 |
Comments in reference to the character Joe Malsmith a Human: (Add Comments Here)
|
|
|
|
| 05/28/04 |
Comments in reference to the character Andrew Sáralondë a Half-Elf: Good session. The DM put your character in a tough situation that made it harder for you to effectively roleplay, but you still did well. Ideally, there should have been two DMs in order for you to be allowed to roleplay your character properly. I look forward to playing with you again in the future.
|
|
|
|
| 05/27/04 |
It was great fun to play with Andrew Saralonde. He seemed like a challenging character to portray but you handled him expertly. Great interaction with the strange familiar Shim, roleplaying that made you want to know more about him, and a mature RP approach to conflict all made this a character and player I hope to adventure with again sometime. Cya around.
---Tairis Laroi (DjinnX)
|
|
|
|
| 05/06/04 |
Comments in reference to the character Andrew Sáralondë a Half-Elf: Once again thorougly impressed, you can‘t help develop emotions about this character, one way or the other. Look forward to next week.
|
|
|
|
| 05/06/04 |
Comments in reference to the character Andrew Sáralondë a Half-Elf: Good game. I‘d like to see your character realize the opportunity to become a leader in this situation, and to help resolve the tension between elves and men, and in the process he could try to put his internal struggle behind him. As the only elf in the game, he could be very valuable and come out of this very highly regarded.
|
|
|
|
| 05/06/04 |
Comments in reference to the character Andrew Sáralondë a Half-Elf: This was a fun session to have Saralonde in. You RP‘ed the whole encounter great and the aftermath. BIG.
|
|
|
|
| 04/30/04 |
Comments in reference to the character Andrew Sáralondë a Half-Elf: Nice interactions with the Barbarian Chief.
|
|
|
|
| 04/29/04 |
Comments in reference to the character Andrew Sáralondë a Half-Elf: Saralonde I felt was at his best in this “Barbarians“ session. His proud, sneering exterior was shattered, if perhaps only temporarily, by his encounter with the dragon in the cave. The resulting self-doubt was evident and it seems as if this session could leave Saralonde with some long-term baggage. Also handled the CvC aspects within the party with finesse. Well done. --Carlo
|
|
|
|
| 04/29/04 |
Comments in reference to the character Andrew Sáralondë a Half-Elf: Nice to see the elf opening up to the group a bit. Well, until the end anyway :). A fun character to have around as usual and really did well developing a dynamic with the new guy.
|
|
|
|
| 04/23/04 |
Comments in reference to the character Andrew Sáralondë a Half-Elf: Nice to have Andrew back with us! It‘s tough to jump back into the group after being away so long, but you did a great job. Are we ever going to learn more about Andrew‘s past? Maybe in the third adventure?
|
|
|
|
| 04/18/04 |
Comments in reference to the character Allpowerful a Human: (Add Comments Here)
Good luck with DMing maybe sometime we might coDM a mod or something?
|
|
|
|
| 03/04/04 |
Comments in reference to the character Andrew Sáralondë a Half-Elf: Saralonde continues to develop as the half-elf you love to hate. The personality is well drawn, with Saralonde‘s sneering and generally hostile attitude obviously sourced to his heritage and past. I would caution some prudence in playing him with the group, though. He has done just enough to help so that the others don‘t feed him to the wolves, but he‘s walking a tightrope in-character. --Carlo
|
|
|
|
| 03/04/04 |
Comments in reference to the character Andrew Sáralondë a Half-Elf: (Add Comments Here)
Good roleplaying that is true to his character despite my character hating his guts :)
Good Job!
|
|
|
|
| 03/04/04 |
Comments in reference to the character Andrew Sáralondë a Half-Elf: Good job as usual. I cannot wait to watch this character develop as time goes by.
|
|
|
|
| 03/04/04 |
Comments in reference to the character Andrew Sáralondë a Half-Elf: Great RP as usual. I loved the crazy familiar you summoned. Good job giving it personaltiy too.
|
|
|
|
| 02/19/04 |
Comments in reference to the character Andrew Sáralondë a Half-Elf: An appropriately quiet character. I like that he has elven heritage and was roleplayed with sufficient knowledge and personality.
|
|
|
|
| 02/19/04 |
Comments in reference to the character Andrew Sáralondë a Half-Elf: (Add Comments Here)
|
|
|
|
| 02/12/04 |
Comments in reference to the character Tom Noggin a halfling: It‘s always a pleasure to play with you, since you‘re such a good roleplayer. Tom did not disappoint. Tom went from being the one who least wanted to go on the trip, to the one who didn‘t want to go back home once they got to their destination. Great game. Hope to play with you again some time.
|
|
|
|
| 02/12/04 |
Comments in reference to the character Tom Noggin a halfling: Best player in game. To be honest at first I found him kind of annoying. Which is great because it was excellent RP. At the end of the session his personality rounded out really nicely. Well done.
|
|
|
|
| 02/12/04 |
Comments in reference to the character Tom Noggin a halfling: SCIENCE!! Heehee... I loved Tom so much, the curmudgeony little bugger. He was such a great counterpoint to Poppy! I wish the adventure could have gone on longer; I would have loved to have seen how their interactions progressed. Excellent, excellent job. ~Mag
|
|
|
|
| 01/26/04 |
Comments in reference to the character Jonathan Woodley a Human: (Add Comments Here) Although we didnt get along in game or (IC), this is a good RP‘er who I would play with anytime. Maybe next time we would get along?!?!
|
|
|
|
| 01/26/04 |
Comments in reference to the character Gimel Strongfoot a Dwarf: (Add Comments Here) Had a good time, enjoyed the character hope to play with him again.
|
|
|
|
| 11/23/03 |
Comments in reference to the character Braw Gerdin a Dwarf: Some fantastic roleplaying in this session. You added so many layers to your character in during this game. It was a pleasure. It is so hard to pick a Best Player, but I‘m giving it to you this time. I loved your performance as a dwarf with hurt pride. Great Stuff!
|
|
|
|
| 11/23/03 |
Comments in reference to the character Braw Gerdin a Dwarf: Excellent job role-playing your character. I could really see his crisis of conscience about our course of action and his position in the group and within dwarven society. And of course his infatuation with Solace! Everytime Rave made and advance, you made him feel like he was kicking a puppy-dog! Too much fun. I hope to play with you again.
|
|
|
|
| 11/23/03 |
I have to admit I‘ve never seen a dwarf played so well. Right on the money in term of dwarfish ‘stereotype‘, as in, loves the drink, loves the fight, very proud and sure of himself, and yet so.. well, sentimental.
With mood swings, powerful moral reactions to things that were happening and being said, self doubt.. very complicated character.
Every few minutes or so I was learning of a new facet in Braws personality, and we played off of each other in a beautifully detailed way.
Until next time then
|
|
|
|
| 11/17/03 |
Comments in reference to the character Braw Gerdin a Dwarf: Ruddy good job role-playing your character. Braw was fun to needle and he bristled dwarfishly. You really held your own in a game with more experienced players. I‘m looking forward to playing with you again.
|
|
|
|
| 11/17/03 |
Comments in reference to the character Braw Gerdin a Dwarf: Well played dwarf. Very believable. You are a wonderful part of this group, contributing to conversations and very involved in the story.
|
|
|
|
| 11/17/03 |
Considering this was your first nwCon game you did fantastic. You role played your character very well.
The only problem though i could be wrong here, was i am assuming that your character wasnt the brightest of the bunch. Int of 12 or under im assuming.
So even though you as a person new that the lord had hired bandits it doesn‘t mean your character knows. Otherwise minor mistake and i definitly will not knock ya for it. Great game man and cant wait to play with ya again.
[Allpowerful's reply to comment: Thanks for telling me about that. I did, in fact think that my character would not have been able to deduce that. But unfotunately, that was a few minutes after it happened. Newbie mistake. ]
|
|
|
|
| 11/17/03 |
I really don‘t know which ‘good‘ boxes NOT to ‘tick‘ for you.
Seriously. While Braw Gerdin was at times very rash and brazen, it was played to perfection and with care not to exaggerate and harm actual gameplay.
got into some pretty sticky situations.
You know a player is really good when he can play a rash character who runs headlong into places without looking around but without actually annoying the DM or the other players.
Very well done, can‘t wait for next week.
|
|
|
